Douchy McNitPick

Douchy McNitpick is a character in the Nostalgia Critic character library

Top 11 Nostalgia Critic Fuck Ups
In Douchy's first appearance, he is seen as a parody of hardcore fans. He tells the Nostalgia Critic about his many mistakes he made, resulting in the main Top 11. In the video, he tells Doug his mistakes and sometimes tells him to kill himself for the mistake. In the end, the Nostalgia Critic goes to his house and chases him when he runs away.

The Next Top 11 Fuck Ups
In the sequel, Douchy represents his role in the first video, this time in a new home, his mom's house. In the end, he gets shot by the Critic again.

Willy Wonka vs. Charlie
He appears in the end, revealing to be the one who gives the Nostalgia Critic crappy music he hates, resulting in a Bugs Bunny parody.

You're a Rotten Dirty Bastard - A Christmas Special
In the timeline without the Critic, he never died, being nice to Spooney who replaces the Nostalgia Critic. They seem to be good buddies and Douchy lives at his own house again.

Part 3 Top 11 Fuck Ups: Revenge of the Shit
Douchey actually returns with another Top 11 Fuck Ups. This episode was a little different. Instead of the Nostalgia Critc heading toward Douchey's house and trying to blow his brains out, the Critic has a nervous breakdown about Battlefield Earth and Douchy, out of sympathy, shoots himself out of the picture. He even says, "He the Nostalgia Critic. He remembers it so you don't have to."